Darker textures in Daz Studio

   I have a problem when importing props into Daz Studio; textures are way darker when loaded in Daz Studio than I see them in Substance Painter or the Windows Image Viewer.

   This only happens with Base Color textures, black and white ones are okay. I have checked the gamma; it's 2.2 in render settings, 0 for base color textures and 1 for B&W ones; which I believe it's the standard values. Why is this happening?

   Thanks in advance for your answers!

Comments

  • JonnyRayJonnyRay Posts: 1,744
    Rafmer said:

       I have a problem when importing props into Daz Studio; textures are way darker when loaded in Daz Studio than I see them in Substance Painter or the Windows Image Viewer.

       This only happens with Base Color textures, black and white ones are okay. I have checked the gamma; it's 2.2 in render settings, 0 for base color textures and 1 for B&W ones; which I believe it's the standard values. Why is this happening?

       Thanks in advance for your answers!

    As I recall, if you click on the image file in the surface settings and select Image Editor, then look at the Gamma there. If it is "0" it means it doesn't think there was any gamma information in the file and Studio will make it's best guess. You might try applying a gamma value between 1.6 and 2.2 yourself to see if it helps at all?

  • Richard HaseltineRichard Haseltine Posts: 102,701

    Windows Image Viewer will give the raw image, Substance (if you mean the previwe) and DS are using lighting but their mdoels may be different (certainly the non-Iray modes, but even if both are Iray the light sources won't be the same).

  • RafmerRafmer Posts: 564
    edited July 2019

    Windows Image Viewer will give the raw image, Substance (if you mean the previwe) and DS are using lighting but their mdoels may be different (certainly the non-Iray modes, but even if both are Iray the light sources won't be the same).

    I'm not talking about the rendering result, but the texture image itself. The raw image you can see with the image editor of the surfaces tab of Daz Studio is darker than the one you can see in the Image Viewer.

    Could it be related with the .jpg compression and the way Daz Studio handles it?

    Post edited by Rafmer on
  • Richard HaseltineRichard Haseltine Posts: 102,701
    Rafmer said:

    Windows Image Viewer will give the raw image, Substance (if you mean the previwe) and DS are using lighting but their mdoels may be different (certainly the non-Iray modes, but even if both are Iray the light sources won't be the same).

    I'm not talking about the rendering result, but the texture image itself. The raw image you can see with the image editor of the surfaces tab of Daz Studio is darker than the one you can see in the Image Viewer.

    Could it be related with the .jpg compression and the way Daz Studio handles it?

    I doubt it. Are you actually taking a screen shot and comparing it? If not I'd suspect it was down to the surrounding UI elements in the different applications as those can have a very strong effect on how colour is perceived. Colour Management may also be a factor, I think the Windows viewer does respect it but I don't think DS does (not sure about Substance).

  • RafmerRafmer Posts: 564
    Rafmer said:

    Windows Image Viewer will give the raw image, Substance (if you mean the previwe) and DS are using lighting but their mdoels may be different (certainly the non-Iray modes, but even if both are Iray the light sources won't be the same).

    I'm not talking about the rendering result, but the texture image itself. The raw image you can see with the image editor of the surfaces tab of Daz Studio is darker than the one you can see in the Image Viewer.

    Could it be related with the .jpg compression and the way Daz Studio handles it?

    I doubt it. Are you actually taking a screen shot and comparing it? If not I'd suspect it was down to the surrounding UI elements in the different applications as those can have a very strong effect on how colour is perceived. Colour Management may also be a factor, I think the Windows viewer does respect it but I don't think DS does (not sure about Substance).

    I guess it is just a matter of perception; because I made a screenshot of the image editor and then uploaded the texture to the forum and both looked equally dark in the preview post. I will take it into consideration in my workflow and deal with it. Thanks for your answers.

    JonnyRay said:
    Rafmer said:

       I have a problem when importing props into Daz Studio; textures are way darker when loaded in Daz Studio than I see them in Substance Painter or the Windows Image Viewer.

       This only happens with Base Color textures, black and white ones are okay. I have checked the gamma; it's 2.2 in render settings, 0 for base color textures and 1 for B&W ones; which I believe it's the standard values. Why is this happening?

       Thanks in advance for your answers!

    As I recall, if you click on the image file in the surface settings and select Image Editor, then look at the Gamma there. If it is "0" it means it doesn't think there was any gamma information in the file and Studio will make it's best guess. You might try applying a gamma value between 1.6 and 2.2 yourself to see if it helps at all?

    Yeah, that was the first thing I tried with no changes.

  • PadonePadone Posts: 3,796

    As @JonnyRay says, gamma conversion may not always be handled correctly. This appened to me with some assets and I had to fix it in the image editor. Also to make a fair comparison you have to take a screenshot both in daz and in substance, then upload the sreenshots in the forum. If you upload a daz screenshot and the texture itself you may have different gamma information.

  • RafmerRafmer Posts: 564

    Here is a comparison of the two screenshots; the intended color I chose in Substance and what Daz loads.

    daz preview.jpg
    1920 x 1080 - 441K
    substance preview.jpg
    1920 x 1080 - 442K
  • PadonePadone Posts: 3,796

    It is clearly not the same tint of grey. You can try fixing it with the gamma option in the image editor.

  • RafmerRafmer Posts: 564
    edited July 2019
    Padone said:

    It is clearly not the same tint of grey. You can try fixing it with the gamma option in the image editor.

    Nevermind, switching the gamma to 1 in the base color seems to fix the issue. I don't know why I couldn't see it before; I swear I tried it too.

    Thanks for your help!

    Post edited by Rafmer on
  • RafmerRafmer Posts: 564

    Ok, just a few clarifications to posterity. Variations of the gamma in the image editor do not update in real time when Iray previewing; that might be the cause I didn't fix it before. And second; oddly enough, 1 seems to be the only value in gamma that causes a change in the render; any other value seems to not do anything.

  • RafmerRafmer Posts: 564

    Ok, last report. Changing the gamma to 1 causes artifacts to appear when rendering, so I will just adjust all textures again so I can keep the gamma at 0.

  • RafmerRafmer Posts: 564

    For anyone interested, I discovered when then problem is appearing. Either in the photoshop texture export plugin or the submerger plugin to merge all textures in one image. In one of these plugins the gamma gets modified somehow. Exporting the textures directly from substance painter don't cause any problem.

Sign In or Register to comment.