Face Transfer Squash Faces

Hi, I've been playing around with Face Transfer a lot and I've noticed a problem with some of the results. The nose, lips, cheeks, and chins don't come out right. They get pushed in some. The image below shows a regular G8 figure on the left and the results of a Face Transfer on the right. They look alright when you look at it from the front but when you turn the figure around you see the face got pushed in some. Any ideas what's going on here?

Screenshot (101).png
953 x 834 - 557K

Comments

  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383

    wildbillnash said:

    Hi, I've been playing around with Face Transfer a lot and I've noticed a problem with some of the results. The nose, lips, cheeks, and chins don't come out right. They get pushed in some. The image below shows a regular G8 figure on the left and the results of a Face Transfer on the right. They look alright when you look at it from the front but when you turn the figure around you see the face got pushed in some. Any ideas what's going on here?

    Displayed is the reason why the more expensive face modeling plugins can make use of profile images ;-)

    This product was made to address the issues in Face Transfer: https://www.daz3d.com/face-transfer-shapes-for-genesis-8

     

  • charlescharles Posts: 849
    edited May 2021

    All the plugins are really bad IMO, if you want something goofy, sure, but if you want it to look realistic you'll need to use other sources, combined with blender and then back to DAZ, and LOTS of work. The reason is the sampling is just too poor. You'll never get something like this: 

     

     

     

    Ok you wont' get this in Daz either..well maybe if you try hard enough. This was by a pro in Maya.

     

    Post edited by charles on
  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383

    charles said:

    All the plugins are really bad IMO, if you want something goofy, sure, but if you want it to look realistic you'll need to use other sources, combined with blender and then back to DAZ, and LOTS of work. The reason is the sampling is just too poor. You'll never get something like this: 

    {image removed}

    Ok you wont' get this in Daz either..well maybe if you try hard enough. This was by a pro in Maya.

     

    Actually Daz Studio artists have gotten some excellent results in their artwork - many using Zbrush for morphing and skin texturing. There is at least one product for those tiny face hairs, several for fiber eyelashes ... IMHO hair is the hardest item to get looking realistic although a few artists are getting close. 

    In the meantime, many are quite happy to make use of the D/S plugins {Face Transfer, Headshop, Facegen} to make a likeness or simply another character for the Genesis clans. Not everybody has hundreds or thousands of dollars to blow for one image render.

  • charlescharles Posts: 849
    edited May 2021

    Like you said they are using the 3rd party tool Zbrush, not a photo transfer add on. I've been using FaceBuilder combined with Blender for great results.

     

    Post edited by charles on
  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383

    Well unlike Blender, FaceBuilder is far from free ;-)  For my hobby, the mighty 3 are fine for me :-)

  • charlescharles Posts: 849
    edited May 2021

    Just trying to help, the personal version is only 149, about the same as all those others. And it actually works at a higher detail level you will not get from them. But it's not a couple of clicks and your done type of thing and automatically on your character in Daz, you have shrinkwrap it in Blender on a genesis export.

     I know your good with goofy, but for the OP and anyone else reading this thread.

     

    Post edited by charles on
  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383

    charles said:

    Just trying to help, the personal version is only 149, about the same as all those others. And it actually works at a higher detail level you will not get from them. But it's not a couple of clicks and your done type of thing and automatically on your character in Daz, you have shrinkwrap it in Blender on a genesis export.

     I know your good with goofy, but for the OP and anyone else reading this thread.

     

    Oh I know and that's quite okay charles. But you might want to check your invoice or whatever, that's an annual subscription. The others are not. 

    Actually I do like realistic looking but not "too" ... not into deceiving people as to what they are looking at. For the money, I purchase ready-made from the pros ;-)

  • wildbillnashwildbillnash Posts: 757

    Catherine3678ab said:

    wildbillnash said:

    Hi, I've been playing around with Face Transfer a lot and I've noticed a problem with some of the results. The nose, lips, cheeks, and chins don't come out right. They get pushed in some. The image below shows a regular G8 figure on the left and the results of a Face Transfer on the right. They look alright when you look at it from the front but when you turn the figure around you see the face got pushed in some. Any ideas what's going on here?

    Displayed is the reason why the more expensive face modeling plugins can make use of profile images ;-)

    This product was made to address the issues in Face Transfer: https://www.daz3d.com/face-transfer-shapes-for-genesis-8

    Okay, I liked what you linked to and bought the add-on. But like most things you buy on DS, it doesn't come with instructions (at least none that is easy to find). Any idea on how it works?

  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383
    edited May 2021

    wildbillnash said:

    Catherine3678ab said:

    wildbillnash said:

    Hi, I've been playing around with Face Transfer a lot and I've noticed a problem with some of the results. The nose, lips, cheeks, and chins don't come out right. They get pushed in some. The image below shows a regular G8 figure on the left and the results of a Face Transfer on the right. They look alright when you look at it from the front but when you turn the figure around you see the face got pushed in some. Any ideas what's going on here?

    Displayed is the reason why the more expensive face modeling plugins can make use of profile images ;-)

    This product was made to address the issues in Face Transfer: https://www.daz3d.com/face-transfer-shapes-for-genesis-8

    Okay, I liked what you linked to and bought the add-on. But like most things you buy on DS, it doesn't come with instructions (at least none that is easy to find). Any idea on how it works?

     It is just a set of morphs which will adjust the full head to more realistic shapes. After you have used Face Transfer, then find the morphs on the Parameters Tab and dial in the ones that help the character's overall profile, etc. look more accurate.

    When I first used Face Transfer I was finding that the saved Face Transfer subset would not keep changes. Haven't tried it again yet in 4.15 so if that is still the case, then after your character is looking as good as it gets, no eyelashes, base resolution, send the figure over the bridge to Hexagon. In D/S clear the scene and load in a fresh G8 figure, no eyelashes, base resolution, keep it selected. From Hexagon send the character figure back over the bridge to D/S and create a new morph. {new name} Dial in the morph, go to the geometry editor tool [bones will appear visible], do NOT move the bones, right-click on any bone and Edit - adjust bones to mesh. I select all 3 options at the bottom and accept. Then over on the Parameters Tab, go into Edit mode [right-click on dial] and select ERC. Do NOT touch anything on the pop-up. Again the 3 choices at the bottom should all have checkmarks in them. Click Accept. Now dial out the morph and Save the Morph. File > Save As > Support Asset > Morph. The added bonus for doing fresh morph saves this way is that they can now be used on any new G8 figures loaded into the scene too.

     

    Post edited by Catherine3678ab on
  • wildbillnashwildbillnash Posts: 757

    Rats, that means I will have to redo all of my face transfers. I was hoping just needing to choose a face configuration to correct it. As for what you mentioned, Catherine, I haven't used that bridge at all and only played around with Hexagon a little. Oh well, something else to learn. Thanks for the info.

  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383
    edited May 2021

    wildbillnash said:

    Rats, that means I will have to redo all of my face transfers. I was hoping just needing to choose a face configuration to correct it. As for what you mentioned, Catherine, I haven't used that bridge at all and only played around with Hexagon a little. Oh well, something else to learn. Thanks for the info.

    No, if you have already used Face Transfer, just load the character you've already made. I suggest using Hexagon because "all" one is doing is sending the item over the bridge, to and fro.  {n.b. in D/S under Edit Preferences, the bridge type is Advanced to get all the options}

    .....................................

    Or IF all of this is just for like, one image render, just make the character look nice and render out the image.

    Post edited by Catherine3678ab on
  • wildbillnashwildbillnash Posts: 757
    edited May 2021

    Catherine, you said, " It is just a set of morphs which will adjust the full head to more realistic shapes. After you have used Face Transfer, then find the morphs on the Parameters Tab and dial in the ones that help the character's overall profile, etc. look more accurate." 

    Okay, I loaded one that I did. I looked in the Parameters tab and don't see anything new. What am I missing?

    Just had a thought (don't know why this is highlighting itself), do I find the controls in DS or Hexagon?

    Post edited by wildbillnash on
  • wildbillnashwildbillnash Posts: 757

    Where can I find the morphs? I don't see it them in the parameters tab.

  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383
    edited May 2021

    wildbillnash said:

    Where can I find the morphs? I don't see it them in the parameters tab.

    Okay, I'll be back in a few minutes, have to load up D/S and get the images for you.

    Updating: I will admit that these are not easy to find.
    They are started with "FTS" which can be used as a search term.
    Location is: Actor > Head > Real World > Face Transfer Shapes

    I have loaded to the scene a saved Face Transfer Subset:

     

     

    001 where to find.png
    660 x 654 - 85K
    002 Bridge Advanced Settings.png
    620 x 579 - 17K
    003 here dialing in the main fix.png
    993 x 728 - 297K
    004 send over bridge to Hexagon.png
    1570 x 500 - 191K
    005 load in fresh figure default G8.png
    1549 x 694 - 283K
    006 send morphed figure back into DS.png
    1079 x 579 - 297K
    007.png
    509 x 669 - 38K
    Post edited by Catherine3678ab on
  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383
    edited May 2021

    And the rest of the images:

       

    And now it is safe to fiddle with, add some hair, eye mats, clothes, whatever, and render out images!

    Added bonus: The morph made by Face Transfer can now be used on any G8 M or F figure :-)

     

    008.png
    1000 x 777 - 258K
    009.png
    440 x 688 - 64K
    010.png
    276 x 492 - 19K
    011.png
    508 x 730 - 83K
    012.png
    272 x 249 - 12K
    013.png
    492 x 652 - 45K
    014.png
    614 x 812 - 86K
    Post edited by Catherine3678ab on
  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383
    edited May 2021

    Here is Private G:

    Normal skin settings, etc.

     

    render.png
    1000 x 1000 - 2M
    Post edited by Catherine3678ab on
  • wildbillnashwildbillnash Posts: 757

    Thanks for such detail, Catherine. I found the face morphs not long after my last post. It's where you mentioned. I found it by searching FTS. I just wish the designers of these programs include instructions. These are not video games for you to learn by trail-by-error. There is another location for other adjustements for the chin and nose. What we found only seems to work with the head configuration, not the nose or chin. I found where I can fix that to a degree. I found it under Products/Documents/Face Transfer Shapes for Genesis 8. I really don't understand the settings yet, but it corrects the chin and nose. Then I use 200 Plus I bought a couple of years ago to fine tune them.

    I'm going to have to learn the Hexagon way of things you posted. Meanwhile, I have a lot of correcting to do.

    Thanks again and have a great week.

  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383

    wildbillnash said:

    Thanks for such detail, Catherine. I found the face morphs not long after my last post. It's where you mentioned. I found it by searching FTS. I just wish the designers of these programs include instructions. These are not video games for you to learn by trail-by-error. There is another location for other adjustements for the chin and nose. What we found only seems to work with the head configuration, not the nose or chin. I found where I can fix that to a degree. I found it under Products/Documents/Face Transfer Shapes for Genesis 8. I really don't understand the settings yet, but it corrects the chin and nose. Then I use 200 Plus I bought a couple of years ago to fine tune them.

    I'm going to have to learn the Hexagon way of things you posted. Meanwhile, I have a lot of correcting to do.

    Thanks again and have a great week.

    You're quite welcome wildbillnash, and you as well :-) 

     

  • Catherine3678abCatherine3678ab Posts: 8,383

    Oh yes, if using the same Hexagon session for multiple tasks, everytime one pops back into Hexagon - click on the Accept button to validate/finish the previous action. Then the manipulator returns and the next activity can commence.

Sign In or Register to comment.