I get Daz wants to sell content to other platforms, but can it at least be made for Daz?

2

Comments

  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,316

    I looked at the ad images for the product and thought, this doesn't look like ice cream or even edible, of course it could be because it's not ice cream but gelato, I've never seen gelato so I wouldn't know, it must be a California thing. So I didn't buy it and that seems a fornuate choice now because I was very tempted.

  • JOdelJOdel Posts: 6,288
    edited June 2021

    Leliana released a similar product recently over on Rendo. Hers is for Poser, but hey, shaders.

    Post edited by JOdel on
  • Richard HaseltineRichard Haseltine Posts: 102,724

    Serene Night said:

    TheKD said:

    Serene Night said:

    When this product installs, it dumps all contents in a folder called OBJ No subfolder saying it is gellato. Just OBJ. 

    Also, my version of Studio, doesn't seem to 'see' the mtl files. There is no mtl in the file typelist.

    MTL files are supposed to be loaded automagically when you load the OBJ. Without it there would be no material zones etc

    Interesting. Thanks for enlightening me.

    The bit about the material zones is not correct, those are defined in the OBJ file. The MTL file is loaded automatically and sets the limited number of material properties that OBJ supports for those material groups (surfaces).

  • DiomedeDiomede Posts: 15,225

    I thought this was a Bryce thread.  Then I thought, no, it may be a Carrara thread.  Then I thought.... 3 strikes and I am out.  

  • Serene NightSerene Night Posts: 17,675

    I don't quite get how users are supposed to achieve the look in the picture if there are no textures. When I load the pieces some have colors and some are white. I can go in and color the mat zones, buy in the pictures the textures of the cones have swirls, so its not just default shader with a color on all of them.

  • KrzysztofaKrzysztofa Posts: 226
    edited June 2021

    $25 is too steep a price. The FG ice cream parlor https://www.daz3d.com/fg-ice-cream-parlor has ice cream props but also includes an entire environment and is a comparable price.

    Exnem at Renderosity has a comparable product that even has smart props (link to offsite commercial removed) and its only $12

    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • AllenArtAllenArt Posts: 7,172
    edited June 2021

    nonesuch00 said:

    I looked at the ad images for the product and thought, this doesn't look like ice cream or even edible, of course it could be because it's not ice cream but gelato, I've never seen gelato so I wouldn't know, it must be a California thing. So I didn't buy it and that seems a fornuate choice now because I was very tempted.

    All gelato I've seen looks pretty identical to ice cream.

    As for objects, there is no way I would release a freebie with no prop settings (I only do freebies). It's so easy there's really no reason why it shouldn't be done. All it takes is slightly more time. As for Polygonal Miniatures, I do remember a little bit of backlash, which is probably the reason they stopped doing just objects and switched to DS props.

    Laurie 

    Post edited by AllenArt on
  • benniewoodellbenniewoodell Posts: 1,986

    nonesuch00 said:

    I looked at the ad images for the product and thought, this doesn't look like ice cream or even edible, of course it could be because it's not ice cream but gelato, I've never seen gelato so I wouldn't know, it must be a California thing. So I didn't buy it and that seems a fornuate choice now because I was very tempted.

    Oddly enough when I lived in California, I don't think I ever saw gelato, saw mostly froyo but I also wasn't really looking. Italian restaurants usually have it. I worked at an Italian restaurant in a northern suburb of Chicago fifteen years ago and that's where I was introduced to it. It's really, really good. Oddly enough, I had it every day when I was in Dongguan, China a few years ago. Some woman made it herself and had a little cart inside a mall. Had two scoops every day I was there it was so good. 

  • Serene NightSerene Night Posts: 17,675

    We have gelato stores in california but it isnt as popular as it once was. In my opinion it was overpriced. Frozen yogurt and regular ice cream are still around but less popular. Gelato is in the frozen good section of the supermarket so need to buy it in the store.

  • barbultbarbult Posts: 24,840
    edited June 2021

    Krzysztofa said:

    $25 is too steep a price. The FG ice cream parlor https://www.daz3d.com/fg-ice-cream-parlor has ice cream props but also includes an entire environment and is a comparable price.

    Exnem at Renderosity has a comparable product that even has smart props (link to offsite commercial removed) and its only $12

    It is only $8.40 right now, and it looks much nicer, too. 

    What character(s) do the Smart Props work with?

    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • KrzysztofaKrzysztofa Posts: 226

    barbult said:

    It is only $8.40 right now, and it looks much nicer, too. 

    What character(s) do the Smart Props work with?

    That's a good question, I see no listing for compatible characters. According to the readme it was made August 7, 2020, so I'd bet they're Genesis 8 compatible. I just tried sending Exnem a message, we'll see if they reply.

  • Phoenix1966Phoenix1966 Posts: 1,714
    edited June 2021

    barbult said:

    Krzysztofa said:

    $25 is too steep a price. The FG ice cream parlor https://www.daz3d.com/fg-ice-cream-parlor has ice cream props but also includes an entire environment and is a comparable price.

    Exnem at Renderosity has a comparable product that even has smart props (link to offsite commercial removed) and its only $12

    It is only $8.40 right now, and it looks much nicer, too. 

    What character(s) do the Smart Props work with?

    I have the set. Although even the icons for the smart props and hand grips don't specify, they appear to be made for G8F. You have to manually adjust the position of the props for G8M. 

    ice cream.jpg
    2000 x 1125 - 323K
    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • 3dLux3dLux Posts: 1,231
    edited June 2021

    MeneerWolfman said:

    McGyver said:

    One of the things that early on made me decide to stick to making freebies when it came to DAZ/Poser content was DAZ's fairly high standard of quality... Not that I didn't want to make quality stuff, it's just that in my opinion my "decent" quality stuff was still below DAZ's average.

    Some of the stuff I've been seeing lately is making me rethink that assessment.

    This... So much this. I went from Daz was the golden seal of quality to "If they didn't have a return policy I wouldn't buy anything, because half of what I buy these days is janky and bloated and has to be returned." I'm not happy that this is the case, it's more sad than anything sad At this point Renderotica has better QC cheeky

    Sadly, will return this because of the issues raised here broken heart

    On another note am a product tester at that other site (for a number of years now); opening tickets on 2 other items here that I got yesterday because of errors which I would have flagged when product testing for 'Otica.  Just saying sad 

    Post edited by 3dLux on
  • xyer0xyer0 Posts: 6,057

    Worlds_Edge said:

    I almost made the mistake of getting it, but at the last minute realized it is not made for Daz.  I do think that while it is perfectly ok to sell items not made for Daz, there should be a more conspicuous flagging/warning to prevent accidental purchases.  When most items sold are Daz content, some sort of extra flagging is necessary IMO.  

    yes

    MeneerWolfman said:

    McGyver said:

    One of the things that early on made me decide to stick to making freebies when it came to DAZ/Poser content was DAZ's fairly high standard of quality... Not that I didn't want to make quality stuff, it's just that in my opinion my "decent" quality stuff was still below DAZ's average.

    Some of the stuff I've been seeing lately is making me rethink that assessment.

    MeneerWolfman said: This... So much this. I went from Daz was the golden seal of quality to "If they didn't have a return policy I wouldn't buy anything, because half of what I buy these days is janky and bloated and has to be returned." I'm not happy that this is the case, it's more sad than anything sad At this point Renderotica has better QC cheeky

    Ah, how the mighty have fallen.

  • SummerhorseSummerhorse Posts: 684
    edited June 2021

    Krzysztofa said:

    $25 is too steep a price. The FG ice cream parlor https://www.daz3d.com/fg-ice-cream-parlor has ice cream props but also includes an entire environment and is a comparable price.

    Exnem at Renderosity has a comparable product that even has smart props (link to offsite commercial removed) and its only $12

    Thank you for posting this- those from Exnem are just what I wanted- and  the set has lots of flavors and a sundae too!

    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • barbultbarbult Posts: 24,840
    edited June 2021

    Phoenix1966 said:

    barbult said:

    Krzysztofa said:

    $25 is too steep a price. The FG ice cream parlor https://www.daz3d.com/fg-ice-cream-parlor has ice cream props but also includes an entire environment and is a comparable price.

    Exnem at Renderosity has a comparable product that even has smart props (link to offsite commercial removed) and its only $12

    It is only $8.40 right now, and it looks much nicer, too. 

    What character(s) do the Smart Props work with?

    I have the set. Although even the icons for the smart props and hand grips don't specify, they appear to be made for G8F. You have to manually adjust the position of the props for G8M. 

    Thanks, it looks like a good product. 

    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • AbyssalErosAbyssalEros Posts: 289
    edited June 2021

    barbult said:

    Phoenix1966 said:

    barbult said:

    Krzysztofa said:

    $25 is too steep a price. The FG ice cream parlor https://www.daz3d.com/fg-ice-cream-parlor has ice cream props but also includes an entire environment and is a comparable price.

    Exnem at Renderosity has a comparable product that even has smart props (link to offsite commercial removed) and its only $12

    It is only $8.40 right now, and it looks much nicer, too. 

    What character(s) do the Smart Props work with?

    I have the set. Although even the icons for the smart props and hand grips don't specify, they appear to be made for G8F. You have to manually adjust the position of the props for G8M. 

    Thanks, it looks like a good product. 

    All the food products of Exnem are outstanding and render very nicely—I own several of them. And do not forget to check his clothing products which I really love.

    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • FauvistFauvist Posts: 2,152

    Can't DAZ just separate out all the Made-for-DAZ-Studio content and put it in it's own store.  Frankly, I don't want to waste the time looking through products that don't work in Studio - I don't want to even have to look at them.  Or waste the effort reading every single description of every single product to find out if they work in Studio. 
     

    Shopping at DAZ is like shopping for underwear in a department store, but the underwear isn't in it's own department, the underwear is spread through 7 floors of other departments.  Do you think that would be a fun shopping experience?  

  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,316

    benniewoodell said:

    nonesuch00 said:

    I looked at the ad images for the product and thought, this doesn't look like ice cream or even edible, of course it could be because it's not ice cream but gelato, I've never seen gelato so I wouldn't know, it must be a California thing. So I didn't buy it and that seems a fornuate choice now because I was very tempted.

    Oddly enough when I lived in California, I don't think I ever saw gelato, saw mostly froyo but I also wasn't really looking. Italian restaurants usually have it. I worked at an Italian restaurant in a northern suburb of Chicago fifteen years ago and that's where I was introduced to it. It's really, really good. Oddly enough, I had it every day when I was in Dongguan, China a few years ago. Some woman made it herself and had a little cart inside a mall. Had two scoops every day I was there it was so good. 

    Took me a minute to figure out what froyo is. I like it too. I remember there used to be a TCBY chain and that's where I first tried it. Now for fast food ice cream around here I only know of Baskin Robbins and Dairy Queen. I make fake ice cream now out of chocolate or vanilla flavoured soy milk, (plenty of, otherwise it's like ice cubes and doesn't taste creamy) olive oil, and a couple of stabilizers (agar agar, xanthan gum, soy lethicin).

  • TheKD said:

    Serene Night said:

    When this product installs, it dumps all contents in a folder called OBJ No subfolder saying it is gellato. Just OBJ. 

    Also, my version of Studio, doesn't seem to 'see' the mtl files. There is no mtl in the file typelist.

    MTL files are supposed to be loaded automagically when you load the OBJ. Without it there would be no material zones etc

    The material zones are defined by the usemtl directives in the OBJ file itself. So even without the mtl file, you'd still get the material zones, they just would not have a meaningful material applied to it.

     

  • ColinFrenchColinFrench Posts: 648

    25 bucks? Honestly, from what I've seen of it, this looks like the sort of thing that would be offered as a weekly freebie for PC+ members.

  • McGyverMcGyver Posts: 7,066

    nonesuch00 said:

    I looked at the ad images for the product and thought, this doesn't look like ice cream or even edible, of course it could be because it's not ice cream but gelato, I've never seen gelato so I wouldn't know, it must be a California thing. So I didn't buy it and that seems a fornuate choice now because I was very tempted.

    Gelato is an Italian thing, but it gets around... real gelato has a different texture than ice cream, both as a physical material and a virtual one... real gelato would have an appearance more like melted ice cream as it's denser than ice cream and doesn't have as much air churned into it.

    If it were made into a shader, I suppose the sub surface scattering values would be closer to a "cake frosting" look than what ice cream should look like which would probably be closer to something like dense snow.

    In the promos it looks more like glossy plastic or taffy.

  • WonderlandWonderland Posts: 7,040

    McGyver said:

    nonesuch00 said:

    I looked at the ad images for the product and thought, this doesn't look like ice cream or even edible, of course it could be because it's not ice cream but gelato, I've never seen gelato so I wouldn't know, it must be a California thing. So I didn't buy it and that seems a fornuate choice now because I was very tempted.

    Gelato is an Italian thing, but it gets around... real gelato has a different texture than ice cream, both as a physical material and a virtual one... real gelato would have an appearance more like melted ice cream as it's denser than ice cream and doesn't have as much air churned into it.

    If it were made into a shader, I suppose the sub surface scattering values would be closer to a "cake frosting" look than what ice cream should look like which would probably be closer to something like dense snow.

    In the promos it looks more like glossy plastic or taffy.

    When you order gelato in an italian restaurant, the colors are much more saturated than ice cream, the chocolate can be very dark and dense, fruit flavors are gorgeous bright colors similar to a sorbet but a thicker creamier consistency.

  • barbultbarbult Posts: 24,840

    Moderators removed the link to the Renderosity product, but you can find it easily by searching the Marketplace for Ice Cream.

  • AbyssalErosAbyssalEros Posts: 289

    It's fascinating that Renderosity has no problems linking to DAZ. wink

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,636
    edited June 2021

    AbyssalEros said:

    It's fascinating that Renderosity has no problems linking to DAZ. wink

    I'm not sure that's true - AFAIK, you're not allowed to post Daz links in Rendo forums. As I understand it, the rule for posting Rendo product links here is like a genie wish rule. The link is ok if someone asks, "Can you recommend some good ice cream or gelato products?" But you can't post the link unless someone asks.

    Post edited by Torquinox on
  • TaozTaoz Posts: 9,979

    Torquinox said:

    AbyssalEros said:

    It's fascinating that Renderosity has no problems linking to DAZ. wink

    I'm not sure that's true - AFAIK, you're not allowed to post Daz links in Rendo forums.

    That's also what I understand - unless they have changed the rules recently. 

  • lilweeplilweep Posts: 2,561

    they'll let anything on the daz store these days.

    couldnt you just type "Ice cream" into sketchfab and get 50 or so obj's similar to this for free lol - ones that actually come with textures.

  • SeraSera Posts: 1,675

    This thread is responsible for my irresponsible* lunch of froyo today. I haven't had that stuff in years. 

     

    Mmmmm.... sorbet. 

     

    *It's a bad way to get protein, but at least a lot of it was sugar-free.

  • cridgitcridgit Posts: 1,757
    edited May 2022

    Redacted

    Post edited by cridgit on
Sign In or Register to comment.